"A mermaid." No hesitation whatsoever. "And we can have a really huge pond in our back yard and you can just drop your Nina Mermaid in it on this side, and the pirates can go over on that side." She's making all these hand motions...

Ten seconds later..."Or I want to be Tinkerbell."

Then, "But I don't want to grow up! And I can't stop!" She tried pushing the top of her head down, like she could stop herself from getting any bigger. "And I don't want you to be a grandma!" Now she's crying! I don't blame her...picturing myself as a grandma is pretty disturbing for me too!

p.s. These were my mermaid bath toys from about 1982, and now my girls love them too...can't believe I still have them!